The Underappreciated Star Facing Selection Challenges in USA Swimming

Beata Nelson, a standout swimmer from Wisconsin, has been a key figure on the U.S. National Team for nearly eight years, establishing herself as one of the best short-course swimmers in history. With her exceptional achievements in signature events, Nelson has earned a spot in the all-time rankings. However, despite her immense talent, Nelson has faced significant challenges due to the selection processes within USA Swimming.

Struggles with Short Course Selection

Nelson’s impressive short-course prowess has often clashed with USA Swimming’s selection criteria, which primarily prioritize long-course performances for team selection. Historically, teams for the Short Course World Championships have been focused on developing long-course swimmers. For example, in 2021, despite setting world records, Coleman Stewart and Kelsie Dahlia were not included in the Abu Dhabi Worlds team, and Nelson faced a similar fate in 2022. Even though she was the top women’s performer on the World Cup circuit, Nelson was left off the World Championships team for Melbourne. Her times in the 100 backstroke and 200 backstroke that year would have placed her in top contention, with a silver medal potential in the 200-meter event.

USA Swimming’s Long Course Focus

USA Swimming’s selection procedures are heavily skewed toward long-course swims, particularly for Olympic events. The fastest swimmer in the 50-meter races is selected first, followed by another athlete with the fastest long-course time in their respective 100-meter events. This approach leaves short-course specialists like Nelson at a disadvantage, as their times in short-course events may not always align with long-course criteria.

2024 Olympic Trials: A Strong Showing Despite Challenges

Nelson’s performance at the 2024 Olympic Trials was one of her best, despite not securing a spot on the Olympic team. She made three finals, swimming personal bests in each event. She placed sixth in the 100 butterfly and narrowly missed qualifying by 0.06 seconds in the 100 freestyle. Her 200 IM finish was also strong, securing a fourth-place result.

Looking Ahead

While Nelson did not make the Paris Olympics, she continues to impress on the World Cup circuit, finishing ninth in the rankings and making finals in every event. At just 26, Nelson’s potential remains high, and the future holds plenty of promise for this underappreciated star in USA Swimming.